www.lehmanbrown.com "Providing an Alternative in China"  
insights@lehmanbrown
 
 
Chinese Corporate Finance and International Trade Disputes
[30 May. 2008 Issues 11]

As announced in February of last year (2/15/2006), with the onset of the year new the 1,200 companies listed on the Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchanges have begun to employ the new Chinese Accounting Standards (CAS). The newly implemented metrics are composed of 39 specific standards that have been designed to approach convergence with the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), considered the benchmark in most developed markets .

Among many other interested parties, US business, has consistently advocated a greater degree of transparency into the financial workings of Chinese companies. The ambitiously planned transition was initially greeted with enthusiasm and "widely viewed as a commitment to transparent financial reporting" as well as a further endorsement of market liberalization. CAS adoption should, if properly executed, make it significantly easier for US businesses to outsource, acquire and otherwise partner with financially healthy Chinese firms. Further, while Chinese companies scramble to properly integrate the new standards into their business operations - and with that report perhaps some unattractive figures - US businesses in China may well emerge looking comparatively stronger next to their Chinese competitors . Similarly, a small degree of market instability has been forecasted as another possible consequence of CAS adoption if more stringent standards compel Chinese firms to disclose unsavory information they were previously able to obscure, conceivably leading to corporate setbacks, scandals or even failures .

Inexperienced, overwhelmed and understaffed Chinese accounting firms and internal corporate controllers will likely enlist the help of more versed western firms to navigate and fulfill CAS's new requirements and the sector is poised to benefit . PRC Vice Minister of Finance Jun Wang reaffirmed in a speech in late last year his country's need and desire to learn from their counterparts abroad, "[by] using the education and training system of overseas professional organizations, [and] helping domestic professional talents acquire oversees practicing qualifications" . US accounting firms should enjoy a multitude of new opportunities in china's financial services sector.

As with nearly all meaningful policy reforms, practice and implementation will present the largest hurdles and likely dictate the extent of success. Many in the accounting arena were surprised by the little time allotted for compliance and the un-phased manner of the convergence and are thus understandably skeptical of company comprehension and compliance . PricewaterhouseCoopers notes that other countries (Japan and the United Kingdom) converged in a series of phases and even then underestimated the magnitude of the change and the effort it required . Chinese media outlets are, in fact, already predicting some confusion and instability . In addition, as accurately prepared accounts might well unearth unsightly corporate information, the protection afforded to honest accountants as well as the degree to which accuracy is embraced as paramount, will both be critical variables to which skepticism, reasonably, abounds . While all State-owed enterprises (SOEs) plan to have fully adopted the new standards by the end of 2008, 24 of the country's largest SOEs (Among them: China National Petroleum Corporation (CNPC), China Petrochemical Corporation (Sinopec), Baosteel Group, AirChina, China Mobile) were to have joined the listed companies in compliance from 2007 . CAS, while approaching convergence, still contains notable disparities, especially with respect to China's massive State-owned sector. Differences relate to "the accounting for certain government grants; and¡­related party disclosures between State-owned enterprises that have no direct investment relationship" . Because of the abundance of 'related party' transactions among SOEs there are admittedly structural impediments to their accurate recording; nevertheless, these discrepancies still seem to possess an obfuscating potential that runs counter to the spirit of convergence.

The challenges that await this latest effort towards international integration, namely inherent difficulties presented by SOEs, otherwise shallow financial markets and a questionable willingness and ability to accurate disclosure are certainly equally as significant as the ostensible benefits. Future developments will surely continue this confrontation of liberalizing and constricting forces.

 

  

services@lehmanbrown.com

     Professional Services

     Taxation

     Financial Accounting

     Management Solutions

     Business Management

     Corporate Restructuring

 


TAX


"Zeng Zhi Shui"
(Value Added Tax)


"Ying Ye Shui"
(Business Tax)

 

"Providing an alternative in China"

insights@lehmanbrown provides updates of the latest business news, taxation and accounting regulations in the People's Republic of China. It is designed to provide you with interesting and informative information to assist in your dealings with China or any China-related issues that you may encounter. If you do not wish to receive this newsletter, we have provided an un-subscribe facility below.

LehmanBrown also provides a monthly newsletter Peeling the Onion which investigates certain topical issues affecting businesses in China, particularly for those companies and individuals with operations in the PRC, or looking to establish a presence in-country.

Recent editions include:

Due Diligence in China Transfer Pricing Strategies in China Business Fraud in China Corporate Valuations in China
Crisis Management in China China's Changing Tax Environment Internal Controls in China Establishing an SME in China
Managing Your China Business Under SARS Treasury Management in China Banking in China Mergers and Acquisitions in China
Bridging the Accounting Standards Gap in China The Changing Role of CFOs and Accountants in China
Transfer Pricing Investigations...When not if!

You can subscribe to these newsletters through our website: www.lehmanbrown.com

 
          All rights reserved © LehmanBrown